skip to Main Content

How to Choose the Right Mediation Attorney for Your Dispute

Finding the right mediation attorney can make a significant difference in resolving your dispute efficiently and amicably. Mediation offers a less adversarial approach than traditional litigation, making it an attractive option for many. In this article, we’ll explore how to choose the right mediation attorney, ensuring you find someone who can effectively guide you through the process.

Understanding Mediation

Mediation is a form of alternative dispute resolution where a neutral third party, known as a mediator, helps disputing parties reach a mutually acceptable agreement. Unlike a judge, a mediator does not impose a decision but facilitates communication and negotiation. This process is often quicker, less formal, and less expensive than going to court.

Benefits of Mediation

  • Cost-Effective: Generally, mediation is cheaper than litigation due to lower legal fees and shorter timelines.
  • Confidentiality: Mediation sessions are private, unlike public court proceedings.
  • Control: The parties have more control over the outcome as they work together to reach an agreement.
  • Preserve Relationships: Especially important in family disputes, mediation can help maintain amicable relationships post-resolution.

When to Hire a Mediation Attorney

What is a Mediation Attorney?

A mediation attorney is a lawyer who specializes in mediation and can act as either a mediator or an advisor during mediation. They have specialized training in conflict resolution and mediation techniques.

When to Hire a Mediation Attorney

You should consider hiring a mediation attorney in situations where:

  • You need help understanding legal rights and options.
  • The dispute involves complex legal issues.
  • You prefer an attorney to represent your interests during mediation.
  • You’re looking for a mediator with legal expertise.

Key Qualities to Look For in a Mediation Attorney

Key Qualities to Look For in a Mediation Attorney

Choosing the right mediation attorney involves evaluating several key qualities:

Experience and Specialization

Look for an attorney with significant experience in mediation, specifically in the type of dispute you’re facing. For example, if it’s a divorce mediation, a lawyer specializing in family law would be ideal.

  • Experience with Similar Cases: Ensure they have handled cases similar to yours.
  • Years of Practice: More years often mean more refined skills.
  • Specialization Areas: Specific knowledge in areas like family law, business disputes, or personal injury.

Certification and Training

Check if the attorney is a certified mediator. Certification ensures they have undergone extensive training in mediation techniques and ethics.

  • Certified Mediator: Look for credentials from reputable mediation organizations.
  • Ongoing Education: Attorneys who keep up with continuing education are more likely to be up-to-date with the latest mediation practices.

Reputation and References

Research the attorney’s reputation within the community and among peers. Client reviews and references can provide insights into their professionalism and effectiveness.

  • Client Testimonials: Look for positive feedback from former clients.
  • Professional References: Recommendations from other attorneys can be valuable.

Communication Skills

Effective communication is crucial in mediation. The attorney should be an excellent listener and able to articulate complex legal concepts clearly.

  • Listening Skills: Ability to understand all parties’ viewpoints.
  • Clarity and Conciseness: Can explain legal matters in understandable terms.

Approachability and Empathy

A good mediation attorney should be approachable and empathetic, making clients feel comfortable and understood.

  • Empathy: Shows understanding and concern for your situation.
  • Approachability: Easy to talk to and accessible.

Steps to Finding the Right Mediation Attorney

Steps to Finding the Right Mediation Attorney

Identify Your Needs

Determine what you need from a mediation attorney. Are you looking for someone to act as a mediator or to advise you during the mediation process? Clarify the type of dispute and specific issues involved.

Research and Shortlist

Use online resources, referrals, and professional directories to compile a list of potential attorneys. Look for those with relevant experience and positive reviews.

  • Online Directories: Websites like Avvo or Martindale-Hubbell.
  • Referrals: Ask friends, family, or other lawyers for recommendations.

Conduct Interviews

Narrow down your list and schedule consultations with the top candidates. Prepare questions to assess their suitability for your case.

  • Consultation Questions: Ask about their experience, approach to mediation, and fees.
  • Case Evaluation: See if they provide a preliminary assessment of your case.

Evaluate Costs

Discuss the attorney’s fees and payment structure. Ensure you understand their billing practices and any additional costs that may arise.

  • Fee Structure: Hourly rates vs. flat fees.
  • Transparency: Clear explanation of all costs involved.

Trust Your Instincts

After meeting with potential attorneys, choose the one you feel most comfortable with and confident in their abilities.

Important Questions to Ask During the Consultation

Important Questions to Ask During the Consultation

  • What is your experience with mediation, particularly in cases like mine?
  • Are you a certified mediator? Can you provide details about your training and certification?
  • How do you approach mediation? What is your style?
  • Can you provide references from past clients?
  • What are your fees and how do you structure your billing?
  • How long do you expect the mediation process to take for my case?

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice

Choosing the right mediation attorney involves careful consideration of their experience, certification, reputation, communication skills, and empathy. By following the steps outlined above, you can find an attorney who will effectively guide you through the mediation process, helping you reach a satisfactory resolution.

Investing time in selecting the right mediation attorney is crucial. It ensures that you have professional support tailored to your specific needs, ultimately leading to a more efficient and positive dispute resolution experience.

Staten Island Mediation Attorney - Erin K. Colgan, P.C.

Staten Island Mediation Attorney – Erin K. Colgan, P.C.

Are you facing a legal dispute and seeking a peaceful resolution? Turn to Erin K. Colgan, P.C., your trusted Staten Island mediation attorney. With a strong commitment to helping clients find amicable solutions, Erin K. Colgan offers expert mediation services designed to resolve conflicts efficiently and effectively.


Why choose mediation? Mediation provides a confidential, less adversarial alternative to traditional litigation. It allows parties to discuss their issues openly and work collaboratively towards a mutually agreeable outcome. Erin K. Colgan is dedicated to guiding you through this process with compassion, professionalism, and a deep understanding of the law.


At Erin K. Colgan, P.C., we specialize in family law, divorce mediation, and other civil disputes. Our goal is to help you achieve a fair resolution while minimizing stress and expense. With years of experience and a proven track record, Erin K. Colgan is the certified mediator you can trust to handle your case with care.

Don’t let a legal conflict disrupt your life. Call Erin K. Colgan, P.C., at (718) 981-5505 today to schedule a consultation. Let us help you find a peaceful path forward. Your solution is just a phone call away.

Back To Top